Where Legal Compliance Meets Business Success
Hotline: +917217863964

Your Path to Financial Success Starts Here

Our expert team is here to guide you every step of the way, helping you navigate the complexities of personal finance.

Book a Meeting

Need Help?

Social Networks

Home / GST Category
GST Litigation

"GST registration is essential for legal business operations and unlocking tax benefits."

Click here
Click here

Enquiry for GST Litigation

GST Litigation

• GST litigation involves legal conflicts that arise under the Goods and Services Tax (GST) framework in India. These disputes typically occur between businesses and GST authorities and can encompass issues such as incorrect tax calculations, errors in claiming tax credits, delays in receiving refunds, or non-compliance with GST regulations.

• For instance, if a business submits a claim for a tax credit (which reduces their tax liability) but the GST department deems the claim invalid, this could spark a dispute. Likewise, if a business fails to pay the correct tax amount or does not file its returns punctually, the GST authorities may impose penalties or send notices, potentially leading to legal action.

• Additionally, GST litigation may arise from uncertainties regarding the applicable GST rate for a particular product or service. For example, a business might believe that a product is subject to a 12% tax rate, while the authorities classify it at 18%, resulting in conflicts.

Types of Notices that the GST department can issue.

Pre-Litigation Notices under

• Section 61: Review of Returns
• Section 65: Notification for Audit by tax authorities.
• Section 66: Special Audit conducted by a Chartered Accountant appointed by tax authorities.
• Section 67: Inspection, Search, and Seizure.
• Section 70: Summons.

Litigation Notices under

• Section 73: A Show Cause Notice (SCN) for Demand under the Normal Period can be issued within 33 months from the due date of GSTR-9.
• Section 74: An SCN for Demand under the Extended Period can be issued within 54 months from the due date of GSTR-9.
• Section 76: Notice for the demand of tax that has been collected but not deposited.

Other Notices Regarding GST Litigation

• Blocking of credit under Rule 86A - 20%/10%/5% ITC Rule - 2A Reconciliation.
• Notice under Sec 79 for remitting the outstanding amount due to a vendor to the department due to vendor default.
• E-Way Bill Notices.
• Investigations by: Intelligence/Preventive/Anti-Evasion/CAG.

What is the GST Litigation Process?

1. Initiation of Dispute

The litigation process starts when either a taxpayer or a GST officer spots an issue, which may include:
- Tax discrepancies or unpaid taxes.
- Denial of input tax credit.
- Non-compliance with GST regulations (like failing to file returns or violations of e-way bill requirements).
- Rejection or delays in GST refunds.

The department might send notices or summons to the taxpayer under relevant GST sections, such as Section 73 for non-fraud cases or Section 74 for fraud cases.

2. Reply to Notices

When a taxpayer receives a notice or show cause notice (SCN), they must reply within the specified timeframe. The response should contain thorough explanations, relevant documents, and reconciliations that address the raised issues.

3. Departmental Adjudication

A GST officer reviews the response to the notice and may arrange a personal hearing. Based on the evidence presented, the officer will issue an order:
- In favor of the taxpayer: The issue is resolved.
- Against the taxpayer: The taxpayer may incur penalties, receive demand notices, or face liability orders.

4. Appeal to First Appellate Authority

• If the taxpayer is not satisfied with the departmental order, they can appeal to the First Appellate Authority (Commissioner of Appeals).
• Time Limit for Filing Appeal: Within 3 months from the date of the order.
• Documents Required:
a) A copy of the departmental order.
b) Grounds for the appeal along with supporting evidence.

5. Appeal to GST Appellate Tribunal (Once Operational)

• If either the taxpayer or the department is unhappy with the First Appellate Authority's decision, they can take the matter to the GST Appellate Tribunal.
• Time Limit: Within 3 months of receiving the appellate order.
• Matters Handled: More complex disputes, including significant tax demands or interpretations of GST law.

6. Appeal to High Court

• If the case involves a significant question of law, the affected party can escalate it to the High Court. Examples of legal questions may include interpretations of GST law, constitutional issues, or jurisdictional matters.
• Time Limit: Within 90 days from the Tribunal's decision.

7. Appeal to Supreme Court

• The last step in the GST litigation process is to appeal to the Supreme Court of India.
• Typically, the Supreme Court only hears cases that have national significance or involve important interpretations of GST laws.

Note:

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)

In certain situations, taxpayers and authorities can settle disputes using methods such as:
• Mediation or conciliation.
• Settlement commissions (for cases where liability is acknowledged along with penalties)

Common Issues in GST Litigation

1. Input Tax Credit (ITC) Disputes: Mismatched ITC Claims, Blocked Credits, Fraudulent ITC Claims, Time-Barred Claims.
2. Tax Classification Disputes: Misclassification of goods or services, leading to disputes over the correct GST rate.
3. E-Way Bill Violations: Failure to generate or incorrectly generating e-way bills during the transportation of goods.
4. GST Refund Issues: Delays in processing GST refunds, particularly for exporters or cases involving inverted duty structures.
5. Anti-Profiteering Disputes: Accusations of not passing on the benefits of GST rate reductions or input tax credits to consumers.
6. Non-Filing or Late Filing of Returns: Notices for failing to file GST returns (e.g., GSTR-1, GSTR-3B) on time.
7. Demand Notices for Tax Shortfall: Issuance of demand notices under Section 73 (non-fraud cases) or Section 74 (fraud cases).
8. Transitional Credit Issues: Errors or disputes related to the transfer of input tax credit from the pre-GST regime.
9. Valuation Disputes: Conflicts regarding the assessment of goods or services for GST purposes.
10. Supply vs. Non-Supply: Disputes concerning whether a particular activity is classified as a taxable "supply" under GST.

Tips to Avoid GST Litigation

1. Ensure Proper Documentation: Ensure thorough documentation of all transactions.
2. Regular Reconciliation: Periodically reconcile GSTR-1, GSTR-3B, and GSTR-2A/2B.
3. Stay Updated: Stay informed about amendments, notifications, and circulars related to GST law.
4. Seek Professional Guidance: Reach out to tax professionals for assistance with complex transactions or unclear legal areas.
5. Respond Promptly to Notices: Timely address any discrepancies or notices from authorities within the required deadlines.

Effective GST Litigation Strategy

1. Understanding the GST Law Thoroughly Stay Updated: Regularly review amendments, notifications, circulars, and judicial precedents to ensure compliance with the latest provisions. GST laws are constantly evolving, and keeping informed is essential to avoid disputes.
2. Maintain Comprehensive Documentation and Records:Accurate and Complete Records: Make sure that all transactions, invoices, tax payments, and returns are thoroughly documented. Discrepancies between GSTR-1, GSTR-3B, and GSTR-2A/2B often lead to disputes.
3. Conduct Periodic Internal Audits GST Compliance Audit: Regular internal audits of GST returns, claims, and transactions can help identify potential compliance issues before they are flagged by tax authorities. This proactive approach can prevent significant disputes.
4. Respond Promptly to Notices Timely Action: Always respond to show-cause notices, summons, or audit notices within the specified time frame. Neglecting to do so can result in penalties or negative legal consequences.
5. Proper Representation: Seek professional assistance (tax consultants, advocates) to prepare and present responses effectively, addressing all points raised by tax authorities in a clear and organized manner.
6. Explore Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR): ADR methods like mediation, which can help lower costs and prevent lengthy court battles.
7. Develop a Strong Legal Argument: Articulate a focused argument backed by relevant facts and legal provisions. Tackle the main issues with precision.
8. Risk Mitigation and Cost Management: Before engaging in lengthy legal battles, assess the costs associated with litigation against the potential benefits of winning the case. For minor disputes, settling may be the more economical choice.
9. Effective Use of Technology and Online Platforms: Stay updated on your case by utilizing digital platforms or case management tools. Keep an eye on important deadlines, hearings, and any decisions made by authorities.
10. Post-Litigation Compliance and Review: After the dispute is settled, make sure to implement all compliance actions as outlined in the final ruling, including settling any outstanding liabilities.

  • FAQ
1. Can GST litigation lead to criminal charges?

Yes, criminal charges can be filed in situations involving:
• Tax fraud or misrepresentation.
• Issuing fake invoices or claiming Input Tax Credit (ITC) without genuine supply.
• Deliberate tax evasion or fraudulent actions that surpass certain thresholds.

• Offering specialized guidance on GST compliance and legal matters.
• Assisting in the response to show-cause notices and the preparation of appeals.
• Representing businesses during hearings with authorities and tribunals.

• Late Filing Penalties: Imposed for submitting returns after the deadline.
• Incorrect ITC Claims: Resulting from failure to meet eligibility requirements.
• Tax Evasion: Which can lead to fines, interest charges, and potential criminal prosecution.
• Non-payment of GST: Associated with under-reporting tax liabilities.

The deadlines for filing appeals vary based on the type of dispute. It's crucial to seek advice from a legal expert to grasp the specific timelines that apply to your situation.

Certain authorities may recommend or promote the use of ADR before resorting to formal litigation. Our legal team can assist you in deciding whether ADR is appropriate for your situation.